Betsy DeVos’ Milwaukee voucher school visit draws fire

By: - September 15, 2019 11:53 pm
Betsy DeVos at a podium at the US Dept of Education

Sec. Betsy DeVos (US Department of Education photo)

US Secretary of Education Betsy DeVos is launching a “Back to School” tour on Monday with a visit to a private voucher school in Milwaukee—a city described by The Department of Education in a press release as the “birthplace of education freedom.”

“Thanks to the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program, now in its 30th year, thousands of students have had the freedom to pursue an education that works for them,” the Department states.

DeVos will tour St. Marcus Lutheran School, where almost all of the students receive school vouchers through the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program. While there, she will host a roundtable on the importance of “education freedom” with parents, students and educators, and deliver keynote remarks, which will be livestreamed on Twitter and Facebook, at 10:10 am.

DeVos is promoting her Education Freedom Scholarship program, which, according to the Department of Education, will offer $5 billion in annual federal tax credits for donations to state-based scholarship funds to “empower students and families to choose the best education setting for them—regardless of where they live, how much they make, and how they learn.”

Milwaukee launched the first school-voucher program in the United States three decades ago, and school vouchers, which use public money to cover the cost of private-school tuition for participating families, have been expanded statewide in Wisconsin, generating mixed results and a great deal of controversy. 

Numerous studies have found that Wisconsin’s voucher students perform no better in reading and math than their public-school peers. A 2018 Wall Street Journal analysis found that voucher students in Milwaukee fared best when they attended schools with few voucher students. But the vast majority of Milwaukee students who receive school vouchers attend schools with high percentages of publicly funded students, the Journal noted.

LifeSkills Academy, one of Milwaukee’s Parental Choice program schools, made headlines when it closed in the middle of the night in December 2013, leaving students stranded, while the school’s owners disappeared with hundreds of thousands of dollars in public funds. Only one of the 66 students at the school scored “proficient” in reading and math.

For years, fly-by-night academies popped up regularly all over Milwaukee to take advantage of school vouchers. With lower standards for teacher education, curriculum, and facilities, schools opened in strip malls, corner stores, and former fast-food restaurants.

“The fly-by-nights are gone now,” says Marva Herndon, a Milwaukee school board member who spent years working to expose shady voucher-school operators in Milwaukee and finally helped set standards that led many of them to be closed by the city’s zoning board. Herndon now sits on the Milwaukee school board, and continues to oppose voucher schools.

The issues of curriculum, teacher training, and the drain on public-school funds remain.

Milwaukee, Racine, and the State of Wisconsin currently run three separate parental-choice programs.

Last year, there were 129 private schools participating in the Milwaukee Parental Choice Program, with a total enrollment of 28,917 students, according to the Department of Public Instruction, at an estimated cost of  $221,800,000, paid for by a reduction in state aid to Milwaukee public schools.

Racine had 26 private schools participating in the voucher program, with a total enrollment of 3,324 students, at an estimated to cost of $25,600,000.

The statewide Wisconsin Parental Choice Program had 213 private schools participating, with a total enrollment of 7,140 students and an estimated cost for the year of $54,600,000. State law requires that these students’ resident public school districts have their state aid reduced by the amount paid to cover their private-school tuition.

Former state Senate Majority Leader Dale Schultz (R-Richland Center), publicly disagreed with former Gov. Scott Walker over his efforts to expand school vouchers, and toured the state to talk about the risk of education budget cuts and a voucher expansion back in 2014.  “We can’t afford one system in this state,” Schultz said of Wisconsin’s public schools in an interview upon his retirement that year. “How we are going to ever have ourselves in a situation of trying to fund two is beyond me.”

Betsy DeVos, who ran the pro-school-choice American Federation for Children before she became Secretary of Education, along with her husband Dick DeVos, personally contributed about $250,000 to then-Gov Scott Walker in 2014, according to the Wisconsin Democracy Campaign

American Federation for Children spent $866,000 on Wisconsin legislative races in 2014 to create what the group’s lobbyist, former Assembly Speaker Scott Jensen, calls “a school choice majority in both houses” of the state legislature.

The school choice lobby is now among the most powerful in Wisconsin.

As more public funds have flowed into private schools through an expanding school-voucher system, there is less money available for public school system. 

Public-school activists in Wisconsin reacted negatively to DeVos’s voucher school visit on Monday.

Secretary DeVos’s visit is occurring as parents in the Palmyra-Eagle School District attempt to save their kids’ school system from closure, and as voters across Wisconsin approved a record amount of school referenda to enhance aging facilities and/or maintain programming,” the Wisconsin Public Education Network declared in a press release.

The Network objected to  Secretary DeVos’ proposal to cut $7.1 billion in federal funding from public schools nationwide, while increasing funding to private and privately operated schools.

As districts struggle to cover costs, vouchers are particularly controversial. Wisconsin Public Education Network put out statements from parents and school officials from around the state, responding to DeVos’ appearance on Monday. 

“Milwaukee students have paid the price of Wisconsin’s failed voucher experiment long enough,” said Jenni Hofschlte, president of Parents for Public Schools-Milwaukee. “Even after 30 years of an unaccountable program that picks and chooses its students, Milwaukee’s voucher program still fails to produce results, while students in Milwaukee Public Schools, and now statewide, pay the price.”

“Vouchers for unaccountable private schools cost the Osceola School District and local taxpayers over $300,000 last year, while the district has had to cut almost $2 million from its budget in the last four years,” said Bob Wright, coordinator of the Saint Croix Valley Friends of Public Education. “Our taxpayers and students deserve better than Betsy DeVos’s privatization scheme!”

 “In Green Bay we are paying out voucher funds to students who have never been in a public school,” said Denise Gaumer Hutchison, Champions of Green Bay Public Schools member. “Vouchers are now taking money away from great public schools who continue to educate all children who walk through their doors.”

“When the country’s Secretary of Education comes to Milwaukee for a politically motivated photo op at a private school, she not only doesn’t help the vast majority of our kids, but she actually harms public education,” said Tom Beebe, former school board member in Fort Atkinson and longtime public-school advocate. “No thank you, ma’am, Wisconsin really doesn’t need you butting in to our business.”

Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Ruth Conniff
Ruth Conniff

Ruth Conniff is Editor-in-chief of the Wisconsin Examiner. She formerly served as Editor-in-chief of The Progressive Magazine where she worked for many years from both Madison and Washington, DC. Shortly after Donald Trump took office she moved with her family to Oaxaca, Mexico, and covered U.S./Mexico relations, the migrant caravan, and Mexico’s efforts to grapple with Trump. Conniff is the author of "Milked: How an American Crisis Brought Together Midwestern Dairy Farmers and Mexican Workers" which won the 2022 Studs and Ida Terkel award from The New Press. She is a frequent guest on MSNBC and has appeared on Good Morning America, Democracy Now!, Wisconsin Public Radio, CNN, Fox News and many other radio and television outlets. She has also written for The Nation, The New York Times, The Washington Post, and The Los Angeles Times, among other publications. She lives in Madison, Wisconsin with her husband and three daughters.