Border officials did not follow guidelines on migrant children’s health care, government investigators find
A Honduran child plays at the Catholic Charities Humanitarian Respite Center after crossing the U.S., Mexico border with his father in McAllen, Texas. | Spencer Platt/Getty Images
U.S. Customs and Border Protection has not consistently followed new guidelines for medical care of migrant children and spent some of the agency’s money designated for “medical care” on unrelated items like printers, speakers and its canine program, according to a new federal investigation.
The U.S. Government Accountability Office, an independent congressional watchdog, found gaps in care across border facilities. Border officials also chose to go against a recommendation from the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention to give the flu vaccine to children who crossed the border into the United States.
The GAO released the findings Wednesday, as members of the U.S. House Homeland Security Committee held a hearing as part of an ongoing investigation of Customs and Border Protection (CBP) policies in light of the deaths of two children at the border in December 2018.
The children, 8-year-old Felipe Alonzo-Gomez and 7-year-old Jakelin Caal, were both Guatemalan and died in different CBP holding facilities in New Mexico and Texas.
“The simple reality is that children shouldn’t be locked up by our government,” U.S. Rep. Val Demings of Florida said in an email. “This administration’s anti-immigrant hysteria has led to deeply inhumane treatment of asylum seekers and others who are seeking legal status here in the United States.”
Demings, who is under consideration to be the vice presidential candidate by presumptive Democratic nominee Joe Biden, is a member of the committee but did not question witnesses at the hearing.
U.S. Rep. Debbie Lesko, an Arizona Republican who sits on the committee, called the children’s deaths tragic but said the federal government isn’t necessarily at fault. “We should start blaming the cartels, don’t you think, and they should be at least partially accountable for children’s death,” she said at the hearing.
Pennsylvania Sen. Bob Casey, a Democrat, asked the GAO to look into the matter in the wake of reports showing what he called an “appalling disregard for the lives of migrant children” at the border. He tweeted Wednesday that the funding for the U.S. Homeland Security Department — which oversees CBP — must carry “clear directives and restrictions to ensure transparency and accountability.”
The Inspector General of the Homeland Security Department released its own findings Wednesday that both children died of natural causes related to the flu and bacterial infections. The Inspector General found there was no misconduct or malfeasance from border patrol agents.
But Dr. Fiona Danaher, a pediatrician whom Democrats asked to review the records, said the agency needs more policies in place to protect children.
“Death by natural causes does not mean death was inevitable,” said Danaher, an instructor of pediatrics at Harvard Medical School.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Democratic lawmakers grilled witnesses from the GAO and Inspector General’s office on whether CBP equips its agents to identify when a child might need further medical help.
“CBP did not provide officers and agents with training to identify medical distress in children, is that correct?” Rep. Cedric Richmond, a Democrat from New Orleans and a member of the committee, asked.
The Homeland Security Department’s Inspector General, Joseph Cuffari, said agents are trained in basic first aid, CPR and trauma care. They had no pediatric training.
Tennessee Republican Rep. Mark Green, a physician, said putting more medical staff at the border may be an unreasonable ask in a country already facing a shortage of doctors in rural areas.
“Where in the world are we going to get the doctors to put somebody at every single crossing?” Green asked.
Richmond opened his remarks with criticism of that perspective.
“It is a proverbial Trumpism, pitting communities against each other. I guess that is where we are going in terms of access to doctors. I just won’t entertain it,” Richmond said. “We are the greatest country in the world.”
Gaps in care
The deaths happened in the midst of a surge at the border that backed up the immigration system last year. CBP apprehended more than twice the number of undocumented migrants from September 2018 to October 2019 than they had in the previous four fiscal years, according to Cuffari.
As a result, cramped and overcrowded detention centers risked becoming breeding grounds for illnesses like the flu. Some people were kept in custody for days or weeks. CBP’s policy is that migrants should not remain in that agency’s custody for more than three days.
In response, the government built new holding facilities designed for children and drafted new policies to consider their medical care. But the GAO found “inconsistent implementation” of the medical care policies and procedures.
For example, GAO found three of 10 border stations it visited in South Texas last November did not have medical staff present to perform assessments. In one week in February, 143 of 373 children taken into custody did not receive basic health checks, according to GAO.
The Centers for Disease Control recommended border patrol offer the flu vaccine to all incoming migrant children. CBP declined to do so, saying it would be too challenging to have enough cold storage for the vaccine or providers to administer it.
“Throughout our work we found CBP did not identify or fully document reasons for their decision not to offer the flu vaccine for those in custody … they did not document how they weighed those costs with benefits for the flu vaccine,” said Rebecca Gambler, a director in the Homeland Security and Justice team at the GAO.
The agency faced public pressure last year to vaccinate children, including protests from groups of doctors outside holding centers in California.
The investigation also found CBP has inconsistently reported deaths in its custody. GAO’s review found that 31 individuals have died in CBP custody from 2014 to 2019. CBP only documented 20 of them in congressional reports. CBP told the congressional watchdog agency it would overhaul record-keeping and send information more consistently.
The current situation for migrants differs starkly from last summer. Many of the new holding facilities erected to process children at the border remain empty. The Trump administration issued new emergency rules during the COVID-19 pandemic that instruct border agents to turn children and almost all other migrants back to Mexico immediately. They are not given a chance to ask for humanitarian protection.
Immigrants who crossed before the order have been in a long holding pattern and legal battle, awaiting decisions on their asylum claims. A federal judge ordered the release of immigrant children this Friday from three family detention centers — one in Pennsylvania and two in Texas — but immigration officials may not allow their parents to leave with them. ICE had no positive COVID-19 cases when they tested at the family residential centers July 2.
‘Something seriously wrong’
Congress approved a $4.5 billion emergency humanitarian-aid package last summer, in response to the situation at the border. The package included a $112 million line item specifically for “consumables and medical care.”
But border agents misspent almost 20% of the money, using it to buy printers, speakers and other facility upgrades, as well as dog food and equipment for its canine program, according to the GAO.
“We concluded that CBP violated the statute under appropriations and should make adjustments,” GAO’s Gambler told lawmakers.
CBP has obligated nearly $87 million of the approximately $112 million. After the congressional watchdog’s investigation, CBP said they would adjust accounts for $17 million that was used for spending not related to medical care. The rest of the money was used for relevant purchases: gloves, masks, clothes, medical equipment and other items.
“There is something seriously wrong with this picture, just as there is something seriously wrong with this administration’s approach to caring for migrants and children,” said Homeland Security Committee Chairman Bennie Thompson (D-Miss.).
The congressional watchdog found CBP made progress in some areas: The agency hired more medical personnel and received guidance and training from health professionals.
Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.