Judge denies Tosa chief’s attempt not to testify in Jay Anderson hearing

By: - March 26, 2021 6:30 am
A picture of Jay Anderson Jr. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)

A picture of Jay Anderson Jr. (Photo | Isiah Holmes)

The second hearing in the John Doe case involving the shooting of 25-year-old Jay Anderson Jr. raised more questions about the 2016 incident. Early in the hours-long hearing, Judge Glenn Yamahiro denied a motion to quash a subpoena calling Chief Barry Weber to offer witness testimony. Weber’s motion to quash relied heavily on the argument that the Wauwatosa Police Department (WPD) was not involved in the shooting investigation.

During the hearing Judge Yamahiro highlighted several reports written by various WPD officers related to the investigation. Some of them describe WPD detectives making contact with potential witnesses near where the shooting happened days after Anderson was killed. Other reports were made by other WPD officers, who recovered surveillance footage from a nearby school which captured the shooting.

Wauwatosa Police Chief Barry Weber. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)
Wauwatosa Police Chief Barry Weber. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)

“It does raise issues,” said Yamahiro, “And I believe some of the testimony in the last date was that some of these interviews took place days after the shooting. So that is inconsistent with my understanding of what it means to turn over an investigation. I don’t know if there was anything done that shouldn’t have been done. But the issue, right now, is whether or not there’s a basis for the chief to testify.”

After denying Weber’s motion to quash the subpoena, Yahahiro set a date for May 4 for the chief to testify. Besides addressing the subpoena against Weber, in the hearing several more witnesses were called to the stand. Among them was former MPD sergeant and current member of Assembly Speaker Robin Vos’ task force on racial justice Pamela Holmes, retired Washington D.C. homicide detective James Trainum as well as Anderson’s father Jay Sr. and fiance Starkeshia Delarosa.

Anderson was sleeping in his car at 3 a.m. in a local park when former WPD officer Joseph Mensah arrived for a routine check. Mensah parked in front of Anderson’s car and activated his squad’s bright take-down lights to illuminate the vehicle. These lights are different from the red and blue emergency lights, which would have automatically activated Mensah’s dash camera if they were turned on.

Officer Joseph Mensah (Screenshot taken from Mensah's Go Fund Me page)
Officer Joseph Mensah (Screenshot taken from Mensah’s Go Fund Me page)

In a statement to MPD investigators, Mensah said it took a couple of attempts to wake the sleeping man. Anderson’s family assert that he was sleeping off intoxication after having gone out with a close friend. Once Anderson was awake, Mensah stated, he asked Anderson for identification, which he claimed Anderson denied having. During the interaction, Mensah stated, he noticed a pistol with an extended magazine sitting beside Anderson on the front passenger seat. At that point, Mensah raised his own weapon and claimed he ordered Anderson not to reach for the gun.

The role of the police in our society has been under a microscope since the killing of George Floyd by the Minneapolis Police Department in May, 2020. Local Policing is an ongoing series analyzing the culture, tactics and actions of departments big and small across Wisconsin. If you have a story to share about your local police, reach out to reporters Isiah Holmes and Henry Redman at [email protected] and [email protected].

That is where the only video which depicts the shooting begins. Mensah stated he attempted to turn on his cameras without success. Anderson’s hands lowered a few times during the interaction, the last time just before he was shot. Mensah claimed Anderson lunged for the weapon, though Trainum testified that Anderson’s wounds and blood spatter don’t indicate any lunging.

Attorney Kimberley Motley brought up several problems with the way Mensah handled the shooting which appear inconsistent with training and policy. First, he parked in front of Anderson’s car rather than behind, which is contrary to how law enforcement officers are trained to position themselves during traffic stops. Second, he failed to activate his emergency lights and therefore did not activate the dash camera.

Problems with the way the scene was handled afterward include other WPD officers removing the gun from Anderson’s car without taking any pictures for evidence. A normal sized, non-extended magazine was also recovered from the back seat. Milwaukee police detectives from the Milwaukee Area Investigative Team (MAIT) had also not yet arrived at the scene, nor had firefighter and medical personnel. An I.D. for Anderson was also recovered by other WPD officers who searched Anderson’s body on the scene.

Jay Anderson Sr. and Linda Anderson watch on as the listening session plays out. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)
Jay Anderson Sr. and Linda Anderson watch on as the listening session plays out. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)

Both Jay. Sr. and Delerosa testified that they were  questioned by MPD investigators about whether Anderson sold drugs and why he had money with him. Anderson worked three jobs, including at Ruby Tuesdays as a cook and did yard work and snow removal with his father. Jay Sr. stated that investigators never asked him if his son was employed, and didn’t ask about his gun.

Motley argues that the Anderson shooting is a case of officer-created jeopardy on the part of Mensah. In other words, his choices and actions contributed to the outcome of the encounter. Part of the purpose of the John Doe hearing is to determine whether probable cause exists to file felony charges against the officer. These could include second-degree reckless homicide and homicide by negligence with a dangerous weapon.

“I can’t say he is criminal, but I can say he is reckless,” Holmes testified. “If this is the way he worked this night, just imagine how many other times he’s been in violation on other calls? It could have all been avoided.” When examining how he approached the car, the fact that he didn’t wait for backup and other factors, Holmes feels Mensah “didn’t take advantage of all that training that we’re taught.”

Lawyer Kimberley Motley speaks to press outside Wauwatosa City Hall after the meeting was over. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)
Lawyer Kimberly Motley speaks to press outside Wauwatosa City Hall after the meeting was over. (Photo by Isiah Holmes)

She also noted parking in front of the car near the park’s only entrance would have created a more dangerous situation for his back-up if a shoot-out actually occurred. The questions surrounding the death of Jay Anderson Jr. have exposed the tensions within suburban Wisconsin.

Motley asked Holmes on the stand why various aspects of the incident weren’t more seriously examined. “When’s the last time you’ve heard about the Wauwatosa Police Department doing anything besides the Black face stuff from years ago?” Holmes noted. “So that they don’t suffer any kind of liability, or have to pay out for this officer’s wrong-doing.” She added, “Sometimes things go wrong. Admit it, and move on. Don’t cover it up.”


Our stories may be republished online or in print under Creative Commons license CC BY-NC-ND 4.0. We ask that you edit only for style or to shorten, provide proper attribution and link to our web site. Please see our republishing guidelines for use of photos and graphics.

Isiah Holmes
Isiah Holmes

Isiah Holmes is a journalist and videographer, and a lifelong resident of Milwaukee, Wisconsin. His writing has been featured in Urban Milwaukee, Isthmus, Milwaukee Stories, Milwaukee Neighborhood News Services, Pontiac Tribune, the Progressive Magazine, Al Jazeera, and other outlets.